Guitar Being a "Chick Magnet"
Now when I first started playing guitar about 11 years ago, I was pretty ignorant of this supposed perk. I just thought it was cool and I could learn some Guns N' Roses songs. Then one day, when I was hesitant about playing something for my sisters, one informed me. And so I began to think, "This guitar thing could turn out to be a pretty awesome life choice."
Yeah, well 11 years down the road I can tell you, not so much. I'm not saying I regret learning how to play guitar, I still like playing and yada-yada but as for a modus operandi for getting girls... its been less than an effective tool.
I mean, I've never really flaunted my guitar playing. I didn't carry it around with me on campus, I didn't open up conversations with "Hey, I'm a guitarist. How you doin'?" When I played for other people I usually played original songs - significantly cutting back on sing-a-long opportunities.
But, when I think about it, I can only ever recall one time when a girl was into me just after seeing me play guitar (and she was kind of a nasty skank). I mean, sure, guitar has helped me close the deal after a girl is already interested, but that doesn't count.
It's particularly useless when you're in a bar filled with other musicians. Then things just boil down to physical appearance, or God forbid, talent.
I'm not saying that a girl is going to suddenly not like you if you drop the "by the way, I play guitar" line on her. But as for being a "Chick Magnet" guitar, you're overrated.