Baseball: The New Exciting Playoffs and The New Pointless Regular Season


The Giants are World Series champs for the third time in five years. The series against the Kansas City Royals was nothing short of a barn burner. It had all the plot twists of an instant classic: close match-ups, exciting comebacks, and nail biting finishes. Madison Bumgarner turned in a spectacular pitching performance for the ages. And when all the dust has cleared the Giants make for the least convincing baseball "dynasty" of all time.
Such is the new age of baseball that we live in. One where two teams can carry a sub .550 winning percentage all the way to the World Series. Baseball, more than any other major North American sport requires time to determine excellence. It is why it has the longest regular season of any sport and why up until the 90s only 4 teams progressed to the playoffs.
Now, with the twice expanded playoff system allowing for 10 teams in each league to compete for the World Series in the post-season, teams like the Giants need to build a roster that can play just well enough to get in and then pull out all the stops in a short series.
It is what it is. Are the Giants a dynasty? I don't think so, but that's mostly a subjective term anyway. What isn't subjective is that they won three World Series in a stretch that saw them have only the 7th best winning percentage (.538) behind the Yankees, Cardinals, Braves, Tigers, Rays, and Rangers.
If these Giants teams had been playing in pre-playoff expansion they would have only even made the playoffs once in the last five years (2010). And the Giant's World Series opponents? They've never faced one that finished the regular season with a record better than fourth in the American League (2010 Rangers 4th, 2012 Tigers 7th, 2014 Royals 4th).
Royals fans loved a postseason run, but their team finished with only 89 wins and a run differential of +27.
All of this points to a truth that has been unquestionably apparent in Major League Baseball for a few years now: Being the "best" doesn't matter.
No sport has the perfect playoff system for finding the truly best team. I a way, that's the whole point. But at a certain point, 162 games feels a bit redundant if they don't really matter. Parity is fun, but if you're going to make the MLB post-season into March Madness, something should probably be done about that pesky regular season.
As logical as it would be, it's unlikely MLB would walk away from all the money that have 162 games every season brings in. Maybe the league could try separating the season and playoffs from each other into two separate trophies, like European soccer leagues. The switch would add value to the regular season but it would also challenge the playoff system in a country where playoffs are all anyone has ever known.
There aren't any easy solutions and as long as the playoffs remain unpredictable and exciting it is unlikely MLB is going to look very hard for one. So, just sit back and cozy up to the idea that you're about to care about June baseball even less than you already do. But keep the popcorn ready when October rolls around.





